« Indicator Squid? | Main | Reading List »

October 11, 2004

Strawberry Fields Forever

As you may have noticed, I’m no knee-jerk promoter of organic farming (I’ll explain why, in a moment), but organic strawberries are worth the extra dollar. The reason is methyl bromide, a potent stratospheric ozone destroyer, which is applied most heavily to strawberry fields. Its use is actually increasing in the US, because of a loophole in the Montreal Protocol, as the New York Times reported Friday.

The problem with organic farming is that it’s a one-dimensional approach to sustainability. Unlike, say, the Food Alliance’s system for certifying responsible growers, the strictures of organic production ban synthetic compounds but not excessive energy use, wasteful packaging, abusive labor conditions, or intercontinental transport. (And a few synthetic compounds may be more sustainable than the natural, but environmentally burdensome, alternatives!)

There are, of course, many organic farmers—the old guard, the heroes of the movement—who do things sustainably and locally. They deserve our political support and our business.

But there are a growing number of larger, commercial growers who don’t. Case in point: we live in Cascadia, the apple basket of the continent. And last time I stopped at the upscale grocer Trader Joe’s, I saw organic apples from New Zealand packed four to a box in plastic clamshells. To me, that’s as emblematic of an unsustainable way of life as a Hummer.

The outsourcing of organic production is, of course, part of the globalization of agriculture generally. The distance our food travels has been increasing, as the Midwest’s Leopold Center has showed (pdf).

Taxing energy, fertilizers, and pesticides at their full ecological cost, while untaxing farmers’ income, is one good way to steer farming toward sustainability. And, in the meantime, at the grocery store, we can weigh “local” as heavily as “organic.” Except, when choosing strawberries, put a finger on the “organic” side of the scale as a favor to the ozone layer.

P.S. Environmental Working Group has a handy guide to pesticides in produce. The dirty dozen are apples, bell peppers, celery, cherries, imported grapes, nectarines, peaches, pears, potatoes, red raspberries, spinach, and—you guessed it—strawberries. Still, this guide tells you what recent research found in the food, not what happened on the farm or en route to your mouth.

Posted by Alan Durning | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834573a7069e200d83457d7d369e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Strawberry Fields Forever:

» The 1% Solutions from WorldChanging: Another World Is Here
Ally Alan Durning, over at Northwest Environment Watch's Cascadia Scorecard reminds us that a number of important solutions are starting to gain measurable impact in... [Read More]

Tracked on Jan 2, 2005 9:39:52 AM

» 2004: The Year of 1% from Earth Share of Washington News
This was the year of small but significant percentages: 1 percent or less. I'm speaking not only of Washington’s governor race, the Montana legislative elections, or the Ohio presidential vote tally. I'm speaking of budding trends toward a durable way ... [Read More]

Tracked on Jan 7, 2005 12:36:47 PM

» 2004: The Year of 1% from Earth Share of Washington News
By Alan Durning, republished from the Cascadia Scorecard Weblog, courtesy of Northwest Environment Watch This was the year of small but significant percentages: 1 percent or less. I'm speaking not only of Washington’s governor race, the Montana legisla... [Read More]

Tracked on Jan 7, 2005 12:38:51 PM

Comments